We're lookig at oneonta and cortland this week, so I'll keep you posted. New Paltz is a very nice school, If I didn't live so close it would be my top choice. The people are super friendly, they have a lot of activites/clubs a typical college campus I guess. Also the town is a collee town and it's full of things to do any day of the week. I highly recommend checking it out. Plus they recently put in new dorms where the bathroom isn't do public. It's 1 bathroom per 4 people.
Also idk if you guys looked at city collge- it may be the only CUNY with a legitimate campus. They have housing with a kitchenette and bathroom so te housing is like apartments, and the tour guide told us that she's an OOS student and she enjoys the campus life- she said it isn't nonexistent